The Great Game of Business Lessons for Insurance & Title Agencies

By /

The Great Game of Business—Lessons for Growing Independent Insurance Agencies and Title Agencies

I recently read The Great Game of Business by Jack Stack, and it’s one of those books that feels simple on the surface but profound once you start applying it. Stack built a struggling manufacturing company into a thriving organization by treating business like a game—one where everyone knows the score, understands the rules, and has a stake in winning.

As I read it, I kept thinking about independent insurance agencies and title agencies. The same principles apply remarkably well. In fact, many agencies struggle not because of market conditions, but because their team doesn’t fully understand how the business actually works.

Here are several takeaways from the book that I believe could be especially helpful for P&C-focused independent insurance agencies and title insurance agencies.

1. People Play Better When They Know the Score

Stack’s central idea is simple: you can’t expect people to care about results if they don’t know how results are measured.

Many agencies track numbers at the ownership level but keep them hidden from the team. Producers may not know retention rates. Agents may not understand profit margins. Service staff may not realize how costly rework or poor documentation can be.

Imagine a football game where the scoreboard is turned off. Players would still run plays, but intensity and strategy would drop dramatically.

For agencies, the “score” might include:

  1. New policies written or new closings this week
  2. Retention rate
  3. Revenue per agent
  4. Close ratio on quotes
  5. Customer satisfaction or reviews
  6. Average premium size
  7. Cost per lead

When your team sees these numbers regularly, behavior changes. Effort becomes more focused. Wins feel real.

In my own companies, I’ve learned that transparency often increases engagement more than incentives alone.

2. Teach Business Literacy to Your Team

Another powerful concept from the book is that employees can’t improve what they don’t understand.

Most people working inside agencies have never been taught how agencies actually make money. They may not realize:

  1. How thin margins can be
  2. The cost of acquiring a new client
  3. Why retention matters more than sales alone
  4. How small inefficiencies multiply over time
  5. How errors impact E&O exposure and profitability

For title agencies, this could include understanding the full workflow of a closing, cost of delays, or impact of communication breakdowns.

When people understand the economics of the business, they start making smarter decisions on their own.

You don’t need an MBA course. Short, simple explanations go a long way.

3. Turn Work into a Game (In a Healthy Way)

Stack didn’t mean business should be trivial—he meant it should be engaging.

Agencies can introduce game-like elements that motivate performance:

  1. Weekly scoreboards
  2. Friendly competitions between teams
  3. Milestone celebrations
  4. Progress tracking toward goals
  5. Visual dashboards in the office or CRM

I’ve seen agencies transform culture simply by posting weekly numbers where everyone can see them.

As someone who enjoys weightlifting and tracking progress in the gym, I’ve noticed the same principle personally: progress motivates progress. When you can see improvement, you want to keep going.

4. Align Everyone Around the Same Goal

Many independent insurance agencies operate with fragmented priorities:

  1. Producers chase new business
  2. Service staff focus on task completion
  3. Management worries about profit
  4. Marketing aims for lead volume

But without alignment, these efforts can conflict.

The Great Game approach says everyone should understand the primary objective of the business and how their role contributes to it.

For most independent insurance agencies and title agencies, the core goals are usually some combination of:

  1. Sustainable growth
  2. Strong retention
  3. Excellent client experience
  4. Profitability
  5. Operational efficiency

When teams see how their daily actions move those goals forward, work becomes more meaningful.

5. Share Success—Financially and Emotionally

Stack emphasizes that if employees help create success, they should share in it.

This doesn’t always mean large bonuses. It can include:

  1. Profit-sharing programs
  2. Performance-based incentives
  3. Recognition and praise
  4. Career advancement opportunities
  5. Celebrating wins together

In agencies, even simple rewards tied to retention, reviews, or growth can reinforce positive behavior.

People want to feel that their effort matters. When they see a direct connection between performance and rewards, engagement rises dramatically.

6. Small Improvements Compound

One of my favorite themes in the book is the power of incremental gains.

Agencies often look for breakthrough strategies—a new carrier appointment, a marketing campaign, a big hire. But steady improvement across many areas usually produces more reliable growth.

Examples of compounding improvements:

  1. Slightly higher close rates
  2. Slightly better retention
  3. Faster response times
  4. More referrals
  5. Improved online reputation
  6. More efficient processes

Over time, these small gains create a significant competitive advantage.

This aligns closely with what we see across hundreds of independent insurance agencies: the most successful ones rarely rely on one big move. They just execute consistently better than everyone else.

7. Leadership Sets the Tone

Perhaps the most important lesson is that this approach starts at the top.

Leaders must be willing to:

  1. Share information openly
  2. Trust their team
  3. Teach continuously
  4. Celebrate progress
  5. Accept accountability

Culture flows downward. If leadership treats the business as a shared mission, the team usually follows.

As a business founder, husband, father, and lifelong learner, I’m constantly reminded that the environment we create influences everything else—at work and at home.

How This Applies Specifically to Agencies

Independent insurance agencies and title agencies operate in relationship-driven industries. Your team’s engagement directly affects client experience, retention, referrals, and growth.

Applying these ideas could lead to:

  1. Higher staff retention
  2. Better client interactions
  3. More consistent growth
  4. Stronger internal culture
  5. Reduced operational chaos
  6. Greater profitability

In other words, you don’t just build a better business—you build a better place to work.

Final Thought

The Great Game of Business isn’t about gimmicks or manipulation. It’s about respect—treating employees as intelligent partners rather than task executors.

When people understand the mission, see the score, and share in the outcome, something powerful happens: they start acting like owners.

And when your team thinks like owners, growth becomes far easier—and far more sustainable.

If you run an independent insurance agency or title agency and feel like your team has untapped potential, this book offers a practical blueprint for unlocking it.

Sometimes the biggest breakthroughs don’t come from new technology or marketing tactics. They come from changing how people inside the organization think, communicate, and work together.

That’s a game worth playing—and winning.

Scroll to Top